The Mezzofanti Guild Language Learning Made Simple

Babbel vs Duolingo: I Honestly Wouldn’t Use Either Of Them


Babbel and Duolingo are two of the most popular and well-known platforms for language learning.

Duolingo’s popularity stems primarily from the fact that it’s a “free” service, whereas Babbel is known by its viral marketing campaigns and TV ads.

I’m sure you’ve seen that bearded hipster who’s in pretty much every Babbel commercial.

I’ll get into the main similarities and differences in detail in just a moment.

But let me just start out by saying that I’m usually not a fan of writing these kinds of comparisons (see my Rosetta Stone vs Duolingo review for example). It’s often like comparing apples and oranges when you take two different platforms with different missions and try to draw comparisons.

I’ll do it anyway today since people ask.

To summarize the main differences:

Duolingo

  1. Duolingo is a “free” platform and its content is sourced from volunteers. It’s not really free though. You’re paying in other ways (I’ll explain below).
  2. It has a paid premium option which removes ads and lets you download content for offline use.
  3. Duolingo’s gamified learning is addictive but lacks any real substance.
  4. Duolingo covers a lot of different languages (33 at the time of this writing – some in beta).

Babbel

  1. Babbel is a paid SaaS product (recurring subscription).
  2. It covers less languages than Duolingo (14 at the time of this writing).
  3. Babbel has a professionally designed learning path and is more comprehensive (but less addictive than Duolingo).
  4. Babbel would be on nobody’s radar if it wasn’t for the enormous advertising investment they’ve made in recent years.

Babbel also includes some elements that are reminiscent of Rosetta Stone (although Rosetta Stone does a better job at it).

Personally, I don’t get much value out of either Duolingo or Babbel and wouldn’t personally rely on them to learn a language.

There are much higher quality language learning resources in my opinion.

 

Duolingo – nothing is ever free!

So I assume that the main reason why you’re comparing Duolingo with Babbel is that one is “free” and the other is not.

Babbel has a recurring charge. Duolingo costs nothing.

It makes perfect sense why people would prefer to use a seemingly free product over a paid one (even though Babbel is inexpensive).

But one thing I’ve been pointing out lately is that Duolingo is not free.

Here’s how Duolingo works:

Every time you go on their platform to learn a language and fill out exercises (fill-in-the-blanks) and so on, those answers you give are actually passed on and sold to major corporations.

You don’t even realize it but you are translating content that gets sold on.

The man who invented Duolingo, Luis Von Ahn, is the same guy who created the CAPTCHA login quizzes.

It’s a genius concept to be fair – they show you some images and ask you to identify something in the images or write the text you see in an image, and then your answer is used to authenticate you.

It’s also sold to a company that wants your answer for whatever purpose that may be.

Well Duolingo works the same way.

You get a service (language learning) and in exchange for your answers that are provided to companies, Duolingo is paid a lot of money.

So really, Duolingo is just a front for crowd-sourced translation.

Most people wouldn’t have a problem with this model.

Some people might see it as a fair exchange (a service for a service).

But I have ethical concerns over it – I don’t want anything of mine given away to people when I can’t see the details or have any control over it. I feel the same way about companies like Google and Facebook who profit off your data and the information you freely provide to them.


UPDATE: I have read some unconfirmed reports online that suggest Duolingo moved away from this model and in place of paid subscriptions for their premium service.

I’m not sure if this is accurate or what the details are at this stage.


 

Duolingo’s UI is a child’s toy – by design

I’ve written extensively about the very clear trend of infantilization in UI.

Particularly with language apps.

Take a look at the UI (design) of the Duolingo website and app – it’s a children’s toy. It’s incredibly babyish and appeals to limited attention spans.

This is a general trend we’re seeing across the board with design.

Duolingo employs cartoon awards, big noises and bright colors.

Babbel doesn’t follow the trend of UI infantilization quite as much – they look a lot more professional and ‘adultish’.

You might think this is an odd argument to make but the dumbing down of interactive learning for adults is concerning.

 

Babbel – even a mediocre app can succeed with enough money thrown at it

The issue I have with Babbel is that it is a very mediocre platform (not bad, not great).


See my Babbel review if you haven’t already where I explain this in great detail.


But it’s becoming more and more of a household name because of the advertising it runs – it’s literally everywhere.

I see it all over Google and social media (relevant ads because I research language content so much) and all over TV.

In fact, my wife who knows very little about language learning trends came up to me recently and asked me:

“Hey, have you used this Babbel app?”

She’s seen it on TV so much that it stuck with her!

So the ads work – they’ve done wonders for Babbel’s brand recognition.

But here’s the thing:

Babbel is not becoming well-known because it’s a great platform.

I usually judge a language resource based on this question – has this product achieved recognition based on its own merit?

Is it unique enough that it stands out and gets organic reach?

Or is it just really good at ad campaigns?

I made a very similar point about Michel Thomas not too long ago – it’s a terrible product that had the advantage of Hollywood celebrity endorsements which catapulted it to fame.

It’s not that Babbel’s a bad app.

It’s just not great.

 

Personally, I prefer neither but Babbel is clearly better than Duolingo

Duolingo and Babbel have some similarities in style but are utterly different overall.

They’ve both derived success in two different ways:

  1. Duolingo has a thriving, organic community of loyal supporters who help build the platform and ‘evangelize’ other people to the platform through Reddit and other social media.
  2. Babbel has become an advertising juggernaut with outside investment that has enabled it to get widespread attention to its very bland, uninspired product.

Duolingo has an army of volunteers and devotees who build it for free. It’s not really free though.

When a product is free, it usually means you are the product.

The language coverage of Duolingo is impressive however and the gamified aspects are clever and fun (provided you don’t spend too much time on it).

Babbel has less languages but does them better than Duolingo.

You can tell that Babbel has actually put effort into hiring language experts to craft proper lessons.

The problem is, the platform is bland and feels uninspiring.

I just don’t get much value out of either Duolingo or Babbel and would get further booking a few cheap sessions on italki. If I had to choose one, it’d be Babbel though, because it’s designed by professionals and doesn’t farm my translations to sell to corporations.

There are also plenty of better language resources that I’ve shared before.


What are your thoughts on Duolingo and Babbel?

Share them below.

Comments

House Rules: I love comments and feedback (positive and negative) but I have my limits. You're in my home here so act accordingly. No advertising. Links will be automatically flagged for moderation.

Got something to share?

  1. For duolingo – how am I translating something that is already translated? How is what I am “translating” being sold when it is already translated. Duolingo gives you a sentence in your learning language and gives you cards with the right translation mixed in, but if you click the other language words the translation is there already to. We as users aren’t doing any translating, just copying their translation? I’m not saying you are wrong, I am confused as to how that works or why.

    1. Well I guess you could ask the same thing about ReCaptcha – they already seem to have the answer so how are they selling your answer?
      To be honest, I’m not sure how the process works internally.
      But it is a well-known and publicly documented fact that Duolingo’s revenue comes (or came) from user translations being sold to big companies like CNN.

Love languages?
JOIN THE GUILD:

Or take a look at my Essential Language Learning Tools.

AS SEEN IN:

BBC